After “Sister”: What to Notice When You Go Home for the Holidays
The SNL sketch “Sister” starts with one text: “Dad fell.” For many families, the holiday visit is the chance to see what is changing before that text comes.
Last week’s SNL sketch “Sister” had a lot of families laughing, and a lot of them recognizing themselves. One text, “Dad fell,” and the daughter quits her job, breaks her lease and moves across the country.
It is a comedy sketch, but the moment it is built on is real. Almost none of the families I met in admissions offices had decided it was time. A crisis had decided for them. Families wait, and it is rarely because they do not care.
The visit before the text
For many families, the holidays are the first time in months that everyone sees a parent in person. The changes are rarely dramatic at first. A missed medication here. A bill that went unpaid there. A refrigerator that tells a different story than the one your loved one tells you on the phone.
The people closest to a parent often miss these changes, and it is not because they are not paying attention. A person’s condition shifts by small degrees, and the family adjusts to each new baseline. They compare today with last week, not with six months ago.
If you live away and come home for a few days, you may be the clearest set of eyes in the room.
Who gets the text
In most families, care responsibilities are not equally distributed. One person, often a daughter, often the one who lives closest, is doing the majority of the caregiving work. That is the joke in “Sister,” and it is also the reality in a lot of homes this week.
If you are the one who flies in, the holiday is a chance to see what your sibling has been carrying. If you are the one who stops by every Tuesday, it may be the first time in a while that someone else sees it with you.
The look across the table
In The Question of When, I tell the story of Frank and Eleanor. It started small. Eleanor began to repeat herself. A story told at dinner had been told at lunch. Frank covered for her, gently redirecting conversations and answering questions meant for Eleanor before the pause became awkward.
Their three children noticed too. They talked about it among themselves in lowered tones and agreed it was something to keep an eye on. They did not agree on what to do about it, and so they did nothing.
Many families know that moment at the holiday table. Someone repeats a story, and the siblings glance at each other. Everybody sees it. Nobody says it.
Pay attention, not inspection
You do not need a clipboard on a holiday visit. The signs that a parent needs more support fall into four categories: safety, medical and clinical, social and emotional, and the condition of the caregiver. I walk through them in Signs Your Elderly Parent Can No Longer Live Alone Safely, and the caregiver signal in When an Adult Child Becomes the Caregiver and When a Spouse Becomes a Caregiver.
Noticing that your father has fallen three times in two months is not the same as deciding his future. It is paying attention to what is happening.
Talk with each other first
The holiday table is not the place to announce that it is time to sell the house. I talked about why in How to Have Difficult Conversations With Aging Parents.
That first conversation is often easier with a sibling or a spouse than with your parent. Compare what each of you has seen. If you see it differently, When Siblings Cannot Agree may help.
Before the text comes
The daughter in the sketch gets one text and has to decide everything at once. The families who get through this best are not the ones with a perfect plan. They are the ones who start early enough to have room to adjust it.
A holiday visit will not answer the question of when. It can tell you whether it is time to start asking.
Chapter Two of The Question of When walks through all four signal categories in detail, along with why families stop seeing what is in front of them.